Eagles Playing On
| YEAR | NAME | SCHOOL | DIVISION |
| 2023 | Kara Maiers | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2023 | Neveah Hildebrandt | Appalachian State University | NCAA l |
| 2023 | Grace Lubben | Northwest Missouri State University | NCAA ll |
| 2023 | Annie Gahan | Northwest Missouri State University | NCAA ll |
| 2023 | Sarah Heick | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2022 | Austyn Crees | Grand View University | NAIA |
| 2022 | Kori Wedeking | University of South Dakota | NCAA l |
| 2022 | Payton Akers | Creighton University | NCAA l |
| 2022 | Reagan Schutte | University of Alabama-Huntsville | NCAA ll |
| 2022 | Alecea Mendoza | University of South Dakota | NCAA l |
| 2021 | Sydney Albaugh | University Nebraska - Omaha | NCAA l |
| 2021 | Isabelle True | St Thomas University | NCAA l |
| 2021 | Jessie Frasher | Grand View University | NAIA |
| 2021 | Randyn Carter | Benedictine University - Mesa | NAIA |
| 2021 | Olivia Richards | Cornell College | NCAA lll |
| 2021 | Alli Ferrari | Missouri Valley University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Erin Hocker | DePaul University | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Rachel Stewart | Missouri Western University | NCAA ll |
| 2019 | Jessi Butler | William Woods University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Lauren Kuch | Grand View University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Lauren Klaausen | Clarke University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Hannah Mausser | Mount Mercy | NAIA |
| 2018 | Natalie Halverson | DePaul University | NCAA i |
| 2018 | DoniRae Mayhew | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Sonya McCormick | Viterbo University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Emilee Meyer | Missouri Southern University | NCAA ll |
| 2017 | Lexi Ferrari | Missouri Southern University | NCAA ll |
| 2017 | Morgan Frost | Missouri Western University | NCAA ll |
| 2017 | Lexi Kinnaird | University of Wisconsin-Green Bay | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Maddie Hansen | North Dakota State University | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Taylor Nearad | Iowa State University | NCAA l |
| 2016 | Nicky Simpson | Truman State University | NCAA ll |
| 2016 | Gabi Carter | Indiana State University | NCAA l |
| Mallory Neubauer | Grand View University | NAIA ll | |
| Chasney Jenkins | Savannah State University | NCAA l | |
| Brooke Prior | Indiana State University | NCAA l | |
| Alicia Crivaro | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Lexi Biehl | Grand View University | NAIA ll | |
| Tara Walls | Upper Iowa University | NCAA ll | |
| Natalie Clark | Mid America Nazarene University | NAIA l | |
| Alex Finn | St. Ambrose University | NAIA | |
| Lexi Quandt | St. Ambrose University | NAIA | |
| Krysta Tutsch | Louisiana Tech University | NCAA l | |
| Sam Belz | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Shyanne Saladino | Missouri Western State University | NCAA ll | |
| Brittney Lash | Northern State University | NCAA ll | |
| Leah Duffe | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA l | |
| Shelby Crist | Upper Iowa University | NCAA ll | |
| Haylee Krack | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA l | |
| Amber Logemann | Miami University | NCAA l | |
| Kayla Tatge | St. Ambrose University | NAIA | |
| Kristin Winter | Luther College | NCAA lll | |
| Jenny Nelson | Winona State University | NCAA ll | |
| Nicole Fisher | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Becca Lowe | University of Wisconsin-Platteville | NCAA lll | |
| Catie Flaucher | Mount Mercy University | NAIA | |
| Jena Malmen | Indiana University | NCAA l | |
| Kara Christensen | Ashford University | NAIA | |
| Amanda Lambreacht | Southern Illinois University Edwardsville | NCAA l | |
| Melissa Walls | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Jami Miller | University of Memphis | NCAA l | |
| Chelsea Parrish | Savannah State University | NCAA l | |
| Kylee Knop | University of South Carolina-Aiken/Upper Iowa | NCAA ll | |
| Molly Link | Winona State University | NCAA l | |
| Carlie Schnoebelen | University of Minnesota-Duluth | NCAA ll | |
| Heather VanHyning | Central Missouri State | NCAA ll | |
| Shannon Aguero | Coe College | NCAA lll | |
| Brianna Williams | Mount Mercy University | NAIA | |
| Sheena Canady | Mount Mercy University | NAIA | |
| Bre Milnes | Northern State University | NCAA ll | |
| Crystal Keiper | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Laura Keiper | Winona State University | NCAA ll | |
| Nicky Van Camp | University of West Florida | NCAA ll | |
| Andrea Swanson | Minnesota State University | NCAA ll | |
| Nikki Price | Minnesota State-Mankato | NCAA ll | |
| Shea Carpenter | Northern Colorado | NCAA l | |
| Arin Pershing | Luther College | NCAA ll | |
| Ashley Westphal | Grand View University | NAIA | |
| Destiny Willer | Grand View University | NAIA | |
| Cari Kinzenbaw | Wartburg College | NCAA lll | |
| Brandi Sargent | University of Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Erin Thimmesch | Grand View University | NAIA | |
| Amber Wood | Iowa State University | NCAA l | |
| Nicole Wood | Drake University | NCAA l | |
| Amber Goodell | Southwest State University | NCAA ll | |
| Nicole Faul | Southwest State University | NCAA ll | |
| Ashley Ockenfels | Coe College | NCAA lll | |
| Traci Finke | Cornell College | NCAA lll | |
| Julie Gerdes | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Tifany Oliver | Grand View University | NAIA | |
| Becky Moses | Kentucky Wesleyan College | NCAA ll | |
| Sara Rebling | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Amy Riley | Lindenwood University | NAIA | |
| Kristi Johnson | University of Northern Iowa | NCAA l | |
| Alison Horton | Central Missouri State | NCAA ll | |
| Brandy Remington | Central Missouri State | NCAA ll | |
| Rachelle Mullan | Cornell College | NCAA lll | |
| Laura Harvel | Northwest Missouri State | NCAA ll | |
| Laura Bichler | Iowa State University | NCAA l | |
| Allison Rohdy | Coe College | NCAA lll | |
| Nicole Jackson | Coe College | NCAA lll | |
| Julie Baker | Oklahoma Panhandle State University | NCAA ll | |
| Kris Havel | Quincy University | NCAA ll | |
| Christina Pleggenkuhle | University of Missouri - St. Louis | NCAA l | |
| Melissa Hess | University of Evansville | NCAA l | |
| Wendi Krejca | Western Illinois University | NCAA l | |
| Sara Mouser | Westmar College | NAIA | |
| Christine Evans | Texas Tech University | NCAA l | |
| Vicky Monson | Avila College | NAIA | |
| Bobbi Jo Applegarth | William Penn University | NCAA lll | |
| Shelly Streb | Ball State University | NCAA l |